You Wouldn’t Lie to Me, Would You?

Have you ever been caught in a lie? Felt a spotlight shine on one of those dirty little secrets you carry around? Bernie Madoff did, and so did I when I told my friend I liked their DIY dye job. They may be in different leagues, but they’re both lies.

So the question is: Why do we lie?

Once upon a time, a Nobel Prize-winning economist named Gary Becker came up with a theory about everyday decisions. Becker theorized that “criminal behavior” could be explained by a very simple cost-benefit analysis. Examining that DIY dye job under Becker’s framework, I made a very logical cost-benefit analysis, weighing how much I cared to tell my friend I disliked the hair, with how much I thought they’d be hurt by the comment. And I made the utilitarian decision not to tell them, realizing that we’d both be better off if I kept my opinions to myself. Becker assumed the cost-benefit analysis could be applied to all situations where a moral dilemma occured. If you wanted to rob a bank, you’d weigh how much you’d potentially gain from the register against the likelihood of being caught, and the punishment you’d receive if you did. Makes sense, doesn’t it?

To his critics, however, Becker’s theory was seen as being too rigid. Simply put: humans aren’t always rational thinkers.
Dan Ariely, a professor of psychology and behavioral economics at Duke University and author of “The (Honest) Truth About Dishonesty,” found that neither money nor the likelihood of being caught had any real influence on whether we cheat. So…why do we cheat, lie, and steal?

Our perceived distance from money matters. In this experiment, Ariely found that it’s easier for us to be dishonest when we’re one step removed from cash. While undeniably more risky, it might actually feel less innocuous to steal millions from shareholders in your company that it would be for you to steal $100 from a charity donation bucket.

1) The lie doesn’t tarnish our positive self-image. Over and over, Ariely found that most people cheat just a little. We seek benefit, so we’ll shave a couple of swings off our golf game or pocket an extra dollar or two. But we also want to see ourselves as a good person, so we’ll take only a smidge so we can still look ourselves in the mirror.

2) We see a difference between money and goods. In one experiment, test takers were paid for all self-reported correct answers in either cash or tokens that could be redeemed for cash. People lied for tokens twice as much as people who lied for cash. (I guess we know why there’s never a pen in the bulk-food section of the grocery store!

3) Blame knock-off handbags. Ariely also found that when people knowingly wear counterfeit products, they loosen their moral codes, making it easier to be more dishonest. Yikes! That fake Louis Vuitton costs a bit more than you thought.

4) Cheating is infectious, but whether you catch it depends on who is cheating. When we witness someone in our own social group (a friend, sibling or colleague) cheat, we think cheating is more socially acceptable and we’re more likely to join in. On the flip side, if we notice an outsider cheating, we actually become more honest in order to distance ourselves from the lying, no-good thief. (This bring to mind a story I once heard about a kettle and pot.)

So what’s the common denominator here? What motivates and regulates those dishonest parts of ourselves? It appears to be less about rational value-judgements and more about complex interactions of our self-image, social pressures, and the amount of abstraction from the object being stolen that we can muster. In short, the “things” that motivate us to act in a certain way, are often completely irrational.

Is this good news? I think so. It means there’s no perfect script. What motivates someone one day may not motivate them the next. And you best believe happening upon that script is a lot more rewarding than rote repetition of a script that motivates all people all of the time. Where’s the fun in that? That’s not the kind of thinking that got us to the moon! And it’s not the kind of thinking that’ll incite the mass behavioral changes the world needs right now. We need all hands on deck, fighting and writing for change in every language we have!

San Bernadino County Wins Outstanding Stormwater Project

SGA is immensely proud to have worked on the re-branding components for the San Bernadino County, “Where Water Meets Community” outreach campaign. Identified by the California Stormwater Quality Association (CASQA) as an outstanding stormwater program, the campaign consisted of a complete brand overhaul to help engage and educate the community in stormwater pollution prevention.

A SUCCESSFUL REBRAND BREATHES NEW LIFE INTO OLD PROGRAMS.

SGA was brought in by San Bernadino County (SBC) to help rebrand their long-running stormwater program because it had reached a “plateau of involvement.” The existing programs were very good, but they lacked a unifying message and strong motivators for citizens to get involved. After all, communities change, and so does the messaging that will successfully work to mobilize them. SGA partnered with SBC to find messaging that would resonate with their communities—without having to reinvent the wheel. Giving credit where credit is due, the public education materials SGA came across were stellar. What changed was the way this information was communicated to the public. The new branding was community-centered and fun—developed to tap into the pride that residents’ already had for their communities. After much deliberation, the rebrand was launched under the unifying brand: “Where Water Meets Community.”

HOW WAS SUCCESS MEASURED?
With data, of course! The new campaign increased stormwater pollution prevention awareness which saw significant increases in public engagement. From pre-to-post rebranding, Facebook followers increased by 143%!

Average website visitors increased by 49%, the average page views went up by 41%, and the e-newsletter subscribers saw a total gain of 46%.

The rebranding efforts for the program showed a rise throughout the household hazardous waste and pet waste outreach programs. Fecal contamination in local streams from improper disposal of dog waste is one of the most widely spread sources of bacteria pollution in the County. After the rebranding and reformulating the messaging to revolve around protecting the community and keeping the County clean and beautiful, the distribution of dog canisters increased 373%.

The biggest measurement of successful for SGA—our client’s happiness!

WHAT DID THE REBRAND LOOK LIKE?
Upon finalizing the details of the new brand with the client, SGA went to work developing a massive multi-media campaign guided by this new unifying messaging and modern design. This campaign included an overhaul of County’s website, a pointed social media campaign, and brand new HHW and pet waste outreach campaign materials. See a few before and after examples here.

WHAT CAN WE LEARN FROM THIS WIN?
While rebranding is not a new concept for commercial entities, it is something that can prove challenging for public agencies. Branding, in the first place, is hard enough. It takes a lot of time, energy, and resources. So—why lay it all by the wayside and start anew? Simply put—because rebranding enables an organization to make itself relevant and get noticed. While rebranding isn’t easy, if its done thoughtfully and correctly, the benefits will certainly outweigh the cost.

What Motivates You to Do the Right Thing?

What motivates you? What makes you tick? And what, if anything, would influence a change in your behavior? Many of us assume that we have the answers, but the truth might not be so simple. While we may consciously think one way, there’s a chance that we subconsciously act in a different way altogether. So, how do we truly know what others are thinking? And is there a way to motivate people to change their behavior?

One way to find these answers and gain insight is to lurk outside of people’s homes and read their electric meters just like a group of graduate students did in a sunny Southern California subdivision just outside of San Diego. They were looking for answers to what motivated people to use less energy in their homes. And while they had a hypothesis, they needed hard facts.

Prior to taking the meter readings, the grad students started the study by showing residents four versions of a brochure. Each brochure had a different motivation for saving energy and residents were asked, “Which one would motivate you the most to use less electricity?” The motivators included:

    1. Energy conservation helps protect the environment
    2. Saving energy saves you money
    3. Energy conservation is the socially responsible thing to do
    4. Your neighbors are already conserving energy

[Break time: Before reading on, take a moment to rank the above four answers from most to least motivating and see how they compare to the residents’ answers.]

The majority of residents answered that the most motivating message was protecting the environment. This was followed by social responsibility, saving money and then neighbors. Great news, right?

Not so fast!

The next phase of this study had the grad students randomly place door hangers with one of the four motivational messages. The hangers were placed at houses in a different part of the community, and the different messages and where they were hung were precisely tracked. Every week for the next month, the grad students returned to read the electric meters at each house to see how the door hanger may have influenced each resident’s energy consumption.

When the researchers tabulated the results, something strange happened. The results were almost exactly the opposite of what the residents had said in the first part of the experiment. Environmental protection and social responsibility had the least impact on energy use, and cost savings did only slightly better. The message about what their neighbors were doing (i.e., the social norm) had by far the best results. In fact, the households that had received the social norm message showed nearly a 10% reduction in energy use over the other three. Even more impressively, these savings continued after a month.

So what’s the moral of the story? First, we aren’t great at predicting what actually influences our behavior. This is important to remember when conducting focus groups or market research. Second, while we like to think of ourselves as high-minded and independent, much of what we actually do is influenced by the actions of those around us.

When putting together a program to motivate people about environmental, public health, or other social issues, it is best to highlight the positive actions other people are already taking. Create materials that provide social proof or show an overall social norm. For most of us, real change isn’t about big ideas. It’s about the simple actions we are all taking. And as individuals, we don’t normally stray too far from the herd.

SGA: How it All Began


In celebration of SGA’s 20th Anniversary, SGA presents the first part of a three-part series, detailing the history  of SGA.

“Stephen just landed a large project with the City of Los Angeles and he asked me to help with a project called Kids Ocean Day,” Samantha Concetti, human resources manager at SGA recalled. “It was SGA’s second year and business was growing. My background was in healthcare, but I was interested and wanted to make a difference. The first task was to coordinate a few thousand kids for a beach clean-up.”

SGA came from humble beginnings. In fact, SGA’s first office was a kitchen counter, where Stephen Groner, SGA President, would eat peanut butter and jelly sandwiches everyday for lunch. After working for nine years as an Environmental Engineer at the County of Los Angeles, Stephen took a chance. He left to launch a one-man marketing firm that aimed at making a difference. It was a decision he has never regretted.

As one of SGA’s first employees, Samantha has seen the growth of SGA; beginning with one man guy with a dream to make a difference to what is now a nationally recognized marketing firm that has  won the coveted Silver Anvil award for best public awareness campaign in the country. SGA now works on projects ranging from environmental issues like stormwater protection and energy conservation to more community-focused issues such as affordable housing and public health. An employee of 18 years, Samantha has seen the transformation from the kitchen counter to what is now a thriving small business with offices in Southern and Northern California.

“SGA’s first contract was with the City of Los Angeles dealing with solid waste issues, then stormwater issues,” Samantha said.

“That’s how it all started. It was just me, Stephen, and lots of Miles Davis,” Samantha continued.

“When we got our first office in Long Beach, we began a monthly lunch tradition to celebrate the work we achieved each month after getting the invoices out.”

All SGAers have come to appreciate the celebration known as the Invoice Lunch. Invoice Lunch continues to this day as a tradition to assemble the in-office team together. Along the way, SGA has adopted other traditions such as book clubs, lunch-hour learning workshops called salons, and monthly potlucks. All these team-building activities are meant to uphold the six founding core values of SGA: Curiosity, Passion, Initiative, Impact, Selflessness, and Fun. These core values are incorporated into all aspects of  SGA’s work, ultimately equipping the SGA team with the tools needed to help clients achieve their goals and to make a difference in their respective communities.

We asked Samantha what’s the one theme that has remained true these past 20 years?

“People who  have worked at SGA have had as much influence in shaping the trajectory of this company as Stephen has had.”

“Every employee that has stepped foot in here has shaped SGA in one way or another,” Samantha said.

Laying the foundation for a positive work environment in the past twenty years has led to a strong foundation to continue making a difference in the world. SGA’s reputation, results-driven work, and two-pronged approach of combining creative ideas with technical marketing research has helped made the company what it is today.

SGA now has clients in various cities, counties, government agencies, non-profits, community organizations and environmental agencies across the state of California and the nation.

Successful campaigns have been launched to develop an umbrella brand with community influencers to deliver anti-littering message to Bay Area residents, promote the recycling of toxic mercury thermostats throughout the state, encourage paint recycling within the Latino Community, get Orange County homeowners to embrace a California Friendly landscape, and incentivize LA residents to capture rainwater.

As Stephen stated, “Teaming with clients, employees and stakeholders to find ways to use marketing to make a difference was a passion.” Stephen continued, “It has been a long and humbling journey from engineering to marketing but having the opportunity to make a difference is pretty amazing.”

Recognizing the SHeroes in Our Lives

 

This month is International Women’s Month! To celebrate, we wanted to discuss powerful women that have worked to create a better environment or community. From environmental specialists to marketing experts to behavior change professionals to social outreach warriors, women have made a big impact in the world. Many of them are pioneers who have paved the way for other accomplished women. At SGA, we admire women who have been successful in using strategic communication and outreach strategies and tactics to advocate for their cause. We asked our inspiring female staff members which strong female figures have influenced them. What tactics did these women use to communicate their message and how has this motivated our staffs with own work?

Audrey Taylor, Project Specialist

My hero is SIMRAN SETHI. Her work in food, sustainability and social change has reshaped the way many people think about our food system and its resilience, an issue I feel passionate about. Through her career as a journalist, Sethi has educated millions on these issues, but she also stresses the importance of getting people to actually engage with them. She tries to connect with the people she tells stories to at a basic, human level, stressing our similar desires and goals rather than our differences. When we frame our work in the most accessible and relatable way possible, that is when we can create true behavior change.

Cherish Aquino, Outreach Specialist

My hero is Dr. SYLVIA EARL. She is known for leading an incredible amount of aquatic expeditions and for making an open-ocean dive, which set the women’s record for a depth of 1,250 feet and served as a way to shine a light on the importance of protecting our oceans. She is known as “Her Deepness” because of this. My favorite quote from her is “I have lots of heroes: anyone and everyone who does whatever they can to leave the natural world better than they found it.”

Jackie Ayala, Project Specialist

My hero is HILDA LUCIA SOLIS, the first Latina to serve in the U.S. Senate and who was a strong advocate for environmental justice. Communities of color are disproportionately affected by polluted neighborhoods and Solis authored the first state law in the nation to codify environmental justice as part of the responsibility of state agencies. She has stated, “I believe our families should have clean air to breath, safe drinking water, and affordable energy sources, regardless of color, race, national origin or income. I will continue to fight to improve our environment, protect our health, reduce global warming emissions, and secure our energy supply for future generations.”

Sara Bethel, Project Specialist

My hero is JANE GOODALL. Jane has inspired me in the field of conservation with her passion and determination, even when other people criticize or undermine her work. Jane Goodall lives her life “in a way that matters” and challenges us to do so as well — for each of us to make a difference in our own unique way in our own sphere of influence. She teaches that it’s important for people to realize that the little choices we make each day, and the consequences of those choices, make a difference. This concept guides me in my social marketing work as I try to encourage others in my outreach efforts to make even small choices because those do in fact benefit the environment.
Every one of these women, both SGA staff and otherwise, have and are currently proving that through hard work and diligence, the glass ceiling can be broken! We can confidently answer the age-old question of who runs the world? Girls!

6 Recycling Resolutions that Make a Big Impact

New year, new you?! In case you haven’t noticed (we barely did), January is almost over and it’s about time for those New Year’s resolutions to either kick into gear or to be kicked to the curb. Either way, we’re not judging! We want to help provide solutions. If you’re not happy with how your current resolutions are panning out, we don’t think it’s too late to come up with new ones – ones we KNOW you’ll keep because they’re easy, they’ll help the environment AND they’ll help you!

All you have to do is… recycle! That’s it. Many of you probably already recycle, right? And you probably already know what common items you can and can’t recycle. Here’s a quick reminder:

    • You CAN recycle: • paper/ cardboard • aluminum • glass bottles, food containers or jars • hard plastic containers and bottles
    • You CAN’T recycle: • plastic shopping bags • polystyrene foam cups or containers • wax paper • food or liquid soiled items

But, what about all those miscellaneous items that you’re not sure about? The odds and ends that wind up in your garbage or on your curb where you hope someone will pick it up and take it off your hands? Guess what! Many of those you can recycle as well! Here’s a list of items you probably didn’t know you could recycle and how to do so:

    • CDs/DVDs: Since the age of CDs and DVDs is coming to an end, many people need an environmentally friendly way to get rid of them! Check out this link to find out how: cdrecyclingcenter.org.
    • Eyeglasses: You can get rid of your old glasses and help a good cause at the same time! Send your glasses here: new-eyes.org and they’ll be sent to those who need them in a developing nation.
    • Mattresses: You’ve got a few options here! If you’re buying a new mattress, find out if the store where you’re purchasing it will recycle your old one for you. You can also see if your local recycling program or Goodwill or Salvation Army does bulk waste collection.
    • Oil filters: If you change your own oil and filter, they can and should be recycled! Most service stations or auto shops will accept them as well as Household Hazardous Waste Centers. Use this link to find a place near you: calrecycle.ca.gov/UsedOil/Filters.
    • Paint: Enter your address at this link: paintcare.org to find a location where you can recycle paint! You can also learn about greener paint options and how to make stored paint last longer before you have to get rid of it.
    • Mercury-added thermostats: As one of our own projects, in 2017, SGA helped the Thermostat Recycling Corporation (TRC) increase mercury-added thermostat recycling in California by about 20%! Through our outreach efforts to consumers, wholesalers, Household Hazardous Waste Centers, school districts, property managers, and many more audiences, we have been able to collect these toxic items and dispose of them in a responsible, safe way! For a limited time, If you have a mercury thermostat, your local utility company is promoting TRC’s $5 rebate for recycling it! Follow this link: recyclehomethermostats.org/california for the rebate form and to find a drop-off location near you.

Now, next time someone asks how your New Year’s resolution is going, you’ll be able to tell them how you’re succeeding, not only for yourself but for the environment as well!

Email Marketing Mistakes to Avoid

Many of our clients use email marketing to get their message out to prospects and customers. It’s a great tool. Email allows for segmentation so you are able to target your message to those who will most want to read it. In fact, 13 percent of all leads come from email marketing and customers are six times more likely to click-through from an email than from a Tweet.

Before committing yourself to email marketing, here are some tips to help you prevent common mistakes.

Understanding what permission is and is not

Not following the CAN-SPAM Act can get you into legal trouble. If a form on your website doesn’t specify that those who supply their address will be contacted by you or if you upload a list of addresses you gathered somewhere else, it means permission is not granted. Spamming recipients is a surefire way to wreck your email marketing efforts.

Not confusing the recipient

Email marketing never should stand on its own. Your branding, colors, fonts and logos, should be part of your email campaign. Make sure links within the email go to your website. If this is not done, it confuses the recipient.

Short and to the point

Keeping in mind the way your emails are received are important. Remember we live in mobile society; 41 percent of email is opened on a device. You have approximately three seconds or less to engage a reader. Give them a picture, paragraph and a point of action. Make your message clear and concise.

Is it about you or the audience?

Not every email is an automatic conversion. Be relevant. Make sure your email messages are not about you and your needs (read: no hard sells). Every one of your emails should focus on your target audience and doing your best to fulfill their needs. If you forget about them, you will lose them.

Not monitoring, measuring, or managing

Possibly more important than creating your email marketing campaign and targeting the right audience is taking a look at the results. If you do not, your future campaigns will suffer.

The data you collect in the email metrics can be a gold mine. Examine open rates and days and times that the email was opened. By doing this, you can find the appropriate time to send future emails.

Find out what was more popular and what links received low (or no) click-throughs.

After three or six months, remove inactive subscribers if they have not opened nor clicked-through. Remember, you want to send to a target audience. If these subscribers are not engaged with your mailings, they are not part of the target audience.

Sign up for SGA’s newsletter to keep up with the latest in community-based social marketing and behavior change.

The Poop on Poop

Dog waste isn’t a topic most people talk about on a daily basis, but this “business” should be discussed. Pet owners who don’t have their dog’s droppings top of mind likely aren’t aware of how harmful it is to our environment when the poop isn’t scooped.

So, I’m out to start and share the conversation. You see, it’s been pretty commonplace in my family. My mother-in-law is English. Born in Ely, Cambridgeshire, she embodies many English ways of thinking, including a love for dogs I believe can only be topped by Queen Elizabeth’s love for her corgis.

When you’ve got a dog lover like this for a relative, you hear everything about dogs: what goes in and what comes out. Over the years, I’ve heard more than I ever intended to hear about dog waste. I didn’t think it was a topic to share beyond the family. Who speaks of poop in polite company?

Well, when I joined SGA, I discovered that everyone in the office talks about dog waste because we know the problems it causes. And now, I want to get you talking about it with your family and other pet-loving friends, too.

Dog waste isn’t fertilizer. It doesn’t help the environment; it hurts it. Dog poop contains unhealthy bacteria. In fact, the EPA estimates that if there was a spot with just two or three days of dog waste from 100 dogs, that would equate to enough bacteria to close all watersheds within 20 miles of such a location. That’s because dog waste that is not picked up washes into these waterways. That bacteria? It can lead to a variety of harmful viruses that can cause intestinal illnesses and kidney disorders in humans. In the book, “The Truth About Dogs,” author Stephan Budiansky states that there are 65 diseases that can be transmitted to humans from dog feces. Some will give you skin rashes, but others can be more harmful and may turn deadly.

So get the conversation going. Let others know the poop on poop. Picking up after your pooch isn’t simply the right thing to do, scooping the poop and disposing it in the trash or toilet keeps it from washing into waterways. This, in turn, keeps our rivers and ocean cleaner for all of us.

Sign up for SGA’s newsletter to keep up with the latest in community-based social marketing and behavior change.

The Question is as Important as the Answer: Thomas Kim


(This biographical piece is part of our series to introduce you to the SGA staff.)

Psychology is fascinating. I dug deep into this during my time at UC Berkeley where I was part of a research team at Haas School of Business and the Department of Cognitive Science. My research focused on cognitive biases and decision making.

Today, I bring this expertise to SGA where I work with a team to conduct market research to gather data on the people we serve. You can’t do marketing in a vacuum; it’s important to understand people so you can effectively reach them.

People have busy minds. We create associations where there are none. We see implications and work to appease a derived social norm. In other words, conducting market research is not just a matter of using the appropriate statistical tools or getting the right answers. It is about seemingly trivial details and asking the right questions.

For example, when you create a survey, some things you have to consider include:

  • Does the order of the questions influence participation?
  • Are the questions independent of each other or does a question change the meaning of the next question?
  • Are you giving a range of answers that are too big or too small?
  • Does the medium of the answer (Likert scale, multiple choice) influence the result?

Likewise, the way you frame or word a question can make a big difference. For example, asking a participant, “Do you believe milk with only 5 percent fat is good for you?” results in very different answers when compared with answers obtained by asking, “Do you believe milk that is 95 percent fat free is good for you?” Although mathematically the same question, one highlights the health concern whereas the other highlights the health benefit.

We gather information in a number of different ways, including:

  • Intercept surveys (going into the field and approaching people)
  • Surveys via mail and email
  • Telephone interviews
  • Focus groups

The method of obtaining the answer is also an important consideration and will depend on what you’re seeking. Conducting a survey of hundreds of people will provide you with a solid data representative of the population. On the other hand, having a focus group with a small group of people in a room allows for a deeper and dynamic dive into the subject.

With the research we do at SGA, we are able to understand our targets and create a more effective message and approach to better tackle our client’s specific needs.

Sign up for SGA’s newsletter to keep up with the latest in community-based social marketing and behavior change.